If you couldn’t find all the secret stamps, I’m here to let you know exactly where to find them and how to make them happen in this walkthrough for the Storyteller Secret Stamp Collection.
In my last walkthrough for Storyteller The Ceremony, we discovered new titles that we needed to solve and we had a lot of fun playing with the Devil, literally.
In the walkthrough below I’ll show you where to find each stamp and how to make it reveal itself. Just follow all the steps I wrote for you and you’ll finish all of them in no time.
1. Romeo & Juliet – Original Story by Shakespeare
Location: Chapter 4 The Cellar – Tragedy – Double Poison
- First scene: Edgar and Lenora get married.
- Second scene: Lenora dies and Edgar cries.
- Third scene: Edgar takes poison.
- Fourth scene: Lenora is revived.
- Fifth scene: Lenora goes to Edgar’s tombstone.
- Sixth scene: Lenora takes poison.
2. Werther – Original Story by Goethe
Location: Chapter 4 The Cellar – Poison – Lenora Drinks Poison
- First scene: Edgar and Lenora get married.
- Second scene: Bernard confesses his love for Lenora.
- Third scene: Bernard takes the poison.
3. Macabre – Isobel Laughs at a Tombstone
Location: Chapter 2 Broken Hearts – Grief – Spouses Reject Each Other
- First scene: Edgar marries Lenora.
- Second scene: Edgar rejects Isobel.
- Third scene: The Devil tricks Edgar that Lenora is dead (tombstone)
- Fourth scene: Edgar marries Isobel.
- Fifth scene: Isobel laughs at Lenora’s tombstone.
4. Excesses – Lenora Falls Asleep
Location: Chapter 4 The Cellar – Envy – Murder of Jealousy
- First scene: Edgar marries Lenora.
- Second scene: Edgar refuses Isobel.
- Third scene: Isobel takes the poison to poison Edgar.
- Fourth scene: Edgar drinks the poisoned wine.
- Fifth scene: Lenora drinks too much wine and falls asleep.
5. Age Difference – Young Dog Old Man Meets Young Man Old Dog Keeps
Location: Chapter 3 Apparitions – Aging – Old Heartbroken Dog Dies Happy
- First scene: Love scene with young Edgar.
- Second scene: Time scene.
- Third scene: Old Edgar falls in love with the young dog.
- Fourth scene: Time scene.
- Fifth scene: Edgar is revived.
- Sixth scene: Young Edgar meets the old dog.
6. Persistence – The End of Time
Location: Chapter 3 Apparitions – Aging – Old Heartbroken Dog Dies Happy
- All scenes: Time scene.
7. Batrachian Affair – Frogs Kissing
Location: Chapter 5 Beauty – Duplicity – A Kiss and a Curse
- First scene: The Prince refuses to kiss the Witch.
- Second scene: The Witch transforms the Prince into a frog in the forest.
- Third scene: The Devil changes the potion in the cauldron.
- Fourth scene: The Witch is transformed into a frog because of the potion.
- Fifth scene: The frog witch and the frog prince meet in the forest.
- Sixth scene: The frog witch and the frog prince kiss.
8. Second Chance – Witch Removes Curse From Prince
Location: Chapter 5 Beauty – Duplicity – A Kiss and a Curse
- First scene: The ugly witch wants to kiss the Prince but he refuses.
- Second scene: The ugly witch transforms the prince into a frog in the forest.
- Third scene: The ugly witch turns herself into a beautiful one with a potion.
- Fourth scene: The beautiful witch meets the frog prince in the forest.
- Fifth scene: The beautiful witch kisses the frog prince to turn him back into a prince.
9. Titanic – Heart Breaks During Shipwreck
Location: Chapter 5 Beauty – Duplicity – A Kiss and a Curse
- First scene: The witch falls in love with the prince in the forest.
- Second scene: The Devil changes her potion.
- Third scene: The witch gets turned into a frog from drinking the potion.
- Fourth scene: The frog witch meets the prince in the forest.
- Fifth scene: The Devil makes a hole into the kissing boat.
- Sixth scene: The prince sinks with the boat while the frog witch watches.
10. Fear – Accepting That Martini
Location: Chapter 8 Secrets – Revenge – Spouse Gets Vengeance
- First scene: The Butler offers the Duchess a martini in the ballroom but she refuses.
- Second scene: The Butler takes the gun.
- Third scene: The Duchess witnesses the ballroom.
- Fourth scene: The Butler comes into the ballroom to look for the Duchess.
- Fifth scene: The Butler puts the gun back.
- Sixth scene: The Butler offers her a martini again and she accepts out of fear.
11. Fright Battle – Mutual Ghost Haunt
Location: Chapter 7 Crown Intrigue – Usurpers – Everyone Sits on the Throne
- First scene: The Baron pushes the Queen off the cliff.
- Second scene: The ghost queen scares the Baron off the cliff.
- Third scene: The ghost queen and the ghost baron haunt each other.
12. Unlikely Match – Baron Marries Knight
Location: Chapter 9 Justice – Matriarch – Queen Beheads All Men
- First scene: The Baron pushes the Queen off the cliff.
- Second scene: The Knight takes the throne and becomes king.
- Third scene: The Baron marries the Knight.
13. Afterlife Love – Queen and Knight Ghost Love
Location: Chapter 11 The King – Purge – Three Head Roll
- First scene: The Baron kidnaps the Queen.
- Second scene: The Queen is saved by the Knight.
- Third scene: The Knight and the Queen have an affair, and the King sees it.
- Fourth scene: The King executes the Knight.
- Fifth scene: The King executes the Queen.
- Sixth scene: The Queen has an affair with the Knight as ghosts.
14. Matriarchy – Queen Marries Maid
Location: Chapter 11 The King – Machiavelli – Baron Rules Alone
- First scene: The Baron pushes the King off the cliff.
- Second scene: The Baron kidnaps the Queen.
- Third scene: The Maid saves the Queen.
- Fourth scene: The Queen marries the Maid.
15. Crown Secrets – King and Queen Catch Each Other Having an Affair
Location: Final Chapter Novels – Love Revolution – Knight and Maid Murder the Monarchs and Have an Affair
- First scene: The King has an affair with the Maid and the Queen sees it.
- Second scene: The Queen imprisons the Maid.
- Third scene: The King saves the Maid.
- Fourth scene: The King imprisons the Queen.
- Fifth scene: The Knight saves the Queen.
- Sixth scene: The Queen has an affair with the Knight and the King sees it.
16. Dragon King – Queen Marries Dragon
Location: Chapter 7 Crown Intrigue – Suitor – The Queen Marries
- First scene: The Baron kidnaps the queen.
- Second scene: The Baron disguises himself as a dragon.
- Third scene: The dragon baron saves the queen.
- Fourth scene: The queen marries the dragon baron.
17. Gluttony – Adam and Eve Get Ingested
Location: Chapter 10 Genesis – Punishment – God is Happy at Everyone
- First scene: Temptation scene with Adam eating from the apple.
- Second scene: Temptation scene with Adam offering Eve an apple.
- Third scene: Temptation scene with Eve offering Adam an apple.
- Fourth scene: Temptation scene with Adam offering Eve an apple.
- Fifth scene: Temptation scene with Eve offering Adam an apple.
- Sixth scene: Temptation scene with Adam offering Eve an apple.
18. William Tell – Pierced Fruit
Location: Chapter 10 Genesis – Punishment – Vengeance – Friedrich Takes Revenge
- First scene: Friedrich and Eve are in love.
- Second scene: Eve is tempted and bites from the apple.
- Third scene: Friedrich sees how Eve is judged and dies.
- Fourth scene: Friedrich takes the gun.
- Fifth scene: Friedrich shoots the snake’s apple.
19. Evil Triumphs – Snake Laughs at Adam and Eve
Location: Chapter 10 Genesis – Repentance – Adam Watches His Love Die
- First scene: Adam and Eve love each other.
- Second scene: Adam bites from the apple.
- Third scene: Adam gives Eve the apple to bite from.
- Fourth scene: Both are judged and die.
- Fifth scene: Temptation scene – the snake laughs at Adam’s ashes.
- Sixth scene: Temptation scene – the snake laughs at Eve’s ashes.
20. Dust to Dust – Two Statues of Ash
Location: Chapter 10 Genesis – Repentance – Adam Watches His Love Die
- First scene: Adam and Eve love each other.
- Second scene: Adam bites from the apple.
- Third scene: Adam gives Eve the apple to bite from.
- Fourth scene: Both are judged and die.
- Fifth scene: Love scene with both of them turned to ashes.
21. Phases – Howling at the Moon
Location: Chapter 12 Monsters – Werewolf – Bernard Drinks Poison
- First scene: Bernard is changing into a werewolf.
- Second scene: The moon phase changes.
- Third scene: Bernard howls at the full moon again.
22. Logical Explanation – Dragon Gets Arrested
Location: Chapter 12 Monsters – Dragon – Queen Gets Baron Arrested
- First scene: Baron disguises himself as a Dragon.
- Second scene: The Dragon Baron scares the detective.
- Third scene: The Baron changes back to himself.
- Fourth scene: The Detective examines the disguise and finds Baron’s fingerprints.
- Fifth scene: Baron disguises himself as a Dragon.
- Sixth scene: The Detective arrests the Dragon.
23. Hard on the Outside – Professor Cries
Location: Chapter 12 Monsters – Vampire – Cured of Vampirism
- First scene: Dracula turns Mina into a vampire at night.
- Second scene: Mina visits the professor.
- Third scene: The professor tells Jon how to kill Dracula.
- Fourth scene: Jon goes to the crypt, finds Mina, and kills her.
- Fifth scene: The professor sees Mina dead and he cries.
24. Low Bar – Mirror Praises Tiny
Location: Chapter 5 Beauty – Deceit – Tiny Gets a Kiss
- First scene: The Mirror tells the Witch that Snowy is more beautiful.
- Second scene: The Witch turns Snowy into a frog in the forest.
- Third scene: The Mirror tells the Witch that the Prince is more beautiful.
- Fourth scene: The Witch turns the Prince into a frog in the forest.
- Fifth scene: The Mirror tells Tiny that he is the most beautiful.
25. Family Bonds – Affair With Cousin
Location: Chapter 13 Drama – Godot – Hatey is Murdered by His Daughter.
- First scene: Hatey tells Bluey he’s his father.
- Second scene: Hatey tells Tiny he’s his father.
- Third scene: Tiny tells Peachy he’s her father.
- Fourth scene: Bluey tells Greeny he’s his father.
- Fifth scene: Peachy and Greeny have an affair not knowing they are cousins.
26. Backstabber – Maid Murders Knight
Location: Final Chapter Novels – Love Revolution – Knight and Maid Murder the Monarchs and Have an Affair
- First scene: The King and Maid have an affair that the Knight sees.
- Second scene: The Knight imprisons the King.
- Third scene: The Maid saves the King.
- Fourth scene: The Maif pushes the Knight off the cliff.
27. Spookier – Terrified Ghost
Location: Chapter 9 Justice – Misfortune – Queen Murders Her Husband
- First scene: The Baron kills the Queen off the cliff.
- Second scene: The ghost Queen sees the Devil and gets scared.
28. Frustration – Make Devil Angry
Location: Chapter 9 Justice – Misfortune – Queen Murders Her Husband
- First scene: The Devil kidnaps the Queen.
- Second scene: The Knight saves the Queen.
- Third scene: The Devil sees the cage empty.
29. Original Fight – Eve Yells at Adam
Location: Chapter 10 Genesis – Repentance – Adam Watches His Love Die
- First scene: Adam bites into the tempting apple.
- Second scene: Adam tempts Eve into biting into the apple as well.
- Third scene: Eve is judged and dies.
- Fourth scene: Eve is revived.
- Fifth scene: Eve goes to Adam and yells at him for tempting her.
30. Ghost Buster – Ghost is Vaporized
Location: Chapter 4 The Cellar – Tragedy – Double Poison (Haunted for Murder)
- First scene: Edgar marries Lenora.
- Second scene: Lenora dies.
- Third scene: Devil messes with the poison getting it on fire.
- Fourth scene: Edgar drinks the firey poison.
- Fifth scene: Edgar spits the firey poison at Lenora’s ghost.
31. Shocked Wives – Lenora and Isobel Realize They Share Their Husband
Location: Chapter 2 Broken Hearts – Grief – Spouses Reject Each Other
- First scene: Edgar marries Lenora.
- Second scene: The Devil tricks Edgar that Lenora is dead (tombstone)
- Third scene: Edgar marries Isobel
- Fourth scene: Isobel and Lenora meet and are shocked they are both married to Edgar.
32. Silence – Make Zypce Sad
Location: Settings – Narrator – Never
- Once you mute the narrator and go back to the book, you’ll get the achievement right away, seeing he can’t narrate the chapters anymore.
Wrapping up
Unless the developers of Storyteller surprise us with new chapters or bonus levels, I’m afraid this is everything you could discover in the game.
I’m sure we’ll see each other again with new games, even if they are not necessarily Netflix-related.